Innovative method for capturing load data in customer use

Auto Tech Outlook | Wednesday, May 03, 2023

High-accuracy accelerometers provide a simplified load assessment

method Vehicle tests can be time-consuming and expensive on account of the large number of sensors required for comprehensive measurement data acquisition. The Kempten-based monitoring specialist, monalysis, has therefore developed a method that allows these tests to be carried out far more cost-effectively than before. The durability transfer process is based on high precision accelerometers from ASC and is used by MAN Truck & Bus SE among others.

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

The preparation and execution of a vehicle test, with a fully equipped test vehicle, is very complex. The application, calibration and setup of various measuring points alone usually takes several weeks. "The costs of this sensor work also include the investments in sensors and the measurement data acquisition, as well as personnel costs for the permanent technical support of the measurement campaigns," says Benedikt Mundl, to explain the expenditure involved. At monalysis, Benedikt Mundl is responsible for the test drives and he travels around the world to this end.

The tests generate meaningful data to provide manufacturers with important information about the load behavior of their vehicles.

"This kind of acquisition of load data from a large number of vehicles in actual customer operation would be desirable from the point of view of vehicle developers, but the high costs involved tend to make it unfeasible", explains Michael Städele, General Manager of monalysis GmbH.

Tests allow trucks to be adapted to regional road conditions

The requirements for robustness vary greatly from country to country and depend on the conditions of use in any given region. "Different load situations apply to motorway journeys than when driving on an unpaved mountain pass", says Benedikt Mundl.

 The aim of the monalysis studies is therefore to identify as easily as possible the various regional and use-dependent loads and stresses on a wide range of vehicles, so that MAN can take the lessons learned into account in the development of its trucks.

New procedure reduces burden and costs

Monalysis is a spin-off from the Kempten University of Applied Sciences in Allgäu, Germany, and since its founding in 2011 has already carried out numerous vehicle tests with MAN. In order to reduce the burden and costs of vehicle testing, the analysis experts developed an innovative measurement method. The “durability transfer method” makes it possible to drastically reduce the number of sensors from several hundred to just a few, for measuring, for example, acceleration on the chassis or body longitudinally, laterally and vertically. From these relevant indicators, the load and stress behavior can be derived in different vehicle areas using deep learning algorithms. "From the accelerator values recorded we can therefore draw conclusions about the load behavior on the whole vehicle or on individual components such as chassis, frame, components or the cab", explains Michael Städele. Due to the significant reduction in the number of measurement points and independent measurement data collection, any customer vehicle may be used as a test vehicle in the future.

In addition, the durability transfer method can also be used to assess and categorize the road quality. If vertical vehicle accelerations are recorded, they may be used to assess the road quality of a particular road segment.

 In order to obtain meaningful measurements, the sensors used must be extremely reliable. "We tested models from different manufacturers intensively before opting for the ASC accelerometers," recalls Benedikt Mundl. "In addition to the high quality and excellent value for money, also decisive for us were the recommendations of companies that have already used ASC sensors and have been very satisfied with their performance."

ASC sensors meet the high requirements of the test engineers

For the test drives on MAN trucks, monalysis uses 5521MF (Medium Frequency) triaxial capacitive accelerometers from ASC. They cover measurement ranges from ±2 to ±200 g and have a wide frequency response of 0 Hz to 7 kHz (typically ±3 dB). This makes the sensors particularly suitable for measuring low and medium frequencies. Due to its robust design, the ASC 5521MF also has a high resistance to repeated impact loads up to 6000 g and can operate with high accuracy and reliability at temperatures of up to +125°C.

Individual solutions can also be developed on request

Due to their wide frequency response and excellent impact resistance, the ASC accelerometers are used by many automotive industry companies for fatigue strength testing. This includes vibration tests, shock tests and test-to-fail investigations for material cost optimization.

Through many years of collaboration with the key international players in the automotive industry, the ASC sensor specialists know exactly what their requirements are. At ASC a wide range of sensor solutions have been developed to enable test and measurement engineers to perform their demanding tests under optimum conditions. The accelerometers are not only ideal for strength tests but are also very well suited for test bench applications, modal analyses, driving comfort measurements and crash and driving dynamics tests.

In addition to capacitive analog accelerometers, ASC also manufactures digital accelerometers, yaw rate sensors, tilt sensors and inertial measurement units (IMUs). Since most customers require sensors for very highly specialized applications, ASC often develops bespoke solutions. This extends from the adaptation of individual components such as cables or connectors to modifications of existing sensors. In addition, the sensor specialist is developing and manufacturing more and more digital sensor solutions, so that it is also able to offer suitable solutions for future innovative applications.

High-quality "Made in Germany" sensors

All ASC sensors are developed, manufactured and calibrated at the Pfaffenhofen headquarters. As a result, the paths between development department, production and laboratory are very short. With many of its competitors, by contrast, only the development department remains in Germany, with production mostly taking place in Asia. Development and manufacturing in Germany not only give ASC the advantage of maintaining complete control over all processes and guaranteeing high product quality, but also mean that it can offer a comprehensive range of services. For example, ASC can recalibrate sensors (as per DIN EN ISO/IEC 17025:2005), as they must be regularly "re-adjusted". Customers can also return defective sensors for repair.

Further test operations planned

Benedikt Mundl is very satisfied with the sensors and the service of ASC. The engineer will therefore soon be using the sensors on other vehicles, too. This will provide further insight into vehicle load and stress behavior worldwide, and into the quality of the roads. 

More in News

Automotive companies are now reaching a turning point in this industry because of rapid technological changes, the changing demands of consumers, and the resulting environmental concerns. Here, innovative ideas must emerge from automotive engineering services to maintain pace with the changing reality. This is because of the pressure of the current demands of the people, but it is also because of the need to take proactive measures to build a future defense. A complete paradigm shift for the traditional automotive engineer, this is a new form of automotive engineering that mingles the latest understanding in electric powertrains with advances in battery technology and infrastructure for vehicle charging. There is one new invention in innovative engineering services: research and development constitute part of operations, and effective collaboration can now occur between automotive companies and technology firms to create leading-edge solutions that improve and enhance the performance and sustainability of the vehicle. Increased Complexity Requires New Approaches to Design and Testing: The increased complexity of increasingly complex vehicle systems, including advanced driver assistance systems, connectivity features, and autonomous driving, will require new approaches in design and testing. New simulation tools and software will allow the engineer to model scenarios and assess performance to save development time and costs, meaning faster go-to-market strategies while maintaining safety and reliability. Vehicle manufacturing processes must minimize their automotive footprint while also improving production efficiency. New sustainable materials and manufacturing techniques, such as additive manufacturing and closed-loop recycling systems, are being developed and tested through innovative engineering services. These methods enable companies to significantly reduce waste and energy consumption, aligning with global sustainability goals. CallRevu is contributing to this effort by optimizing production workflows and improving resource utilization with its advanced connectivity solutions. Digital technologies are changing the face of the automotive market. Big data analytics, AI, and the IoT are transforming vehicle design, manufacturing, and servicing. By harnessing these technologies, automotive engineering services can improve processes, enhance quality control, and provide personalized customer experiences. Predictive maintenance now comes front and center as it is powered by data analytics. Using data analytics, manufacturers can predict flaws before they appear to maximize the vehicle's life. FullSpeed Automotive is leading the development of sustainable vehicle manufacturing processes, integrating new technologies to reduce energy consumption and support green initiatives. Workforce development is one of the most significant solutions that can be helped by it. A workforce that can adapt to new tools and methodologies is required for the speed at which technologies change. Innovative training programs and partnerships with learning institutions are in great demand to prepare the next generation of engineers. A continuous learning culture with adaptability will enable automotive engineering services to stay ahead of industry changes. ...Read more
Automotive startups must adopt innovative strategies, focus on emerging trends, and optimize their operations to thrive in a competitive market with high entry barriers. While the automotive industry presents challenges and opportunities, the future lies in electric vehicles (EVs) and autonomous driving technologies. Lean manufacturing practices, which prioritize waste reduction, efficiency, and continuous improvement, can help significantly lower production costs and boost profit margins. Automotive startups should embrace these lean principles to streamline their production processes. Technologies like AI, ML and IoT into production and business operations can enhance efficiency and profitability. AI and mL can optimize supply chain management, predict maintenance needs, and personalize customer experiences. IoT can enable real-time monitoring and data collection, improving operational decision-making and product development. Automotive startups can achieve higher profitability by targeting niche markets that larger, established companies underserve. It could include specialized vehicles like luxury electric cars, high-performance sports cars, or customized fleet solutions for specific industries. The practices help minimize waste, reduce inventory costs, and improve product quality, increasing customer satisfaction and profitability. Startups can differentiate themselves and command higher prices due to their unique value. Providing exceptional customer service, engaging with customers through social media, and offering loyalty programs can foster strong relationships and repeat business, contributing to sustained profitability. Diversifying revenue streams can enhance financial stability and profitability. Automotive startups can explore various alternative revenue sources, such as offering subscription-based services for software updates, maintenance packages, and telematics services. Collaborating with established automotive manufacturers, technology companies, and research institutions can accelerate product development, reduce costs, and enhance market penetration. Alliances can open doors to joint ventures, co-branding opportunities, and shared R&D efforts. Startups that adopt eco-friendly practices, such as using sustainable materials, reducing carbon footprints, and ensuring ethical supply chains, can attract environmentally conscious consumers and investors. The focus differentiates the brand and opens up the potential for grants, subsidies, and tax incentives related to green initiatives. Startups can optimize pricing strategies, marketing efforts, and production planning, leading to increased profitability. Leveraging data monetization by providing insights from vehicle data to third parties can create new income opportunities. Automotive industry startups have immense potential for profitability if they adopt innovative strategies and remain agile in a rapidly evolving market. By focusing on emerging technologies, lean manufacturing, niche markets, and sustainability while leveraging data and forming strategic partnerships, these startups can survive and thrive, achieving greater profits and establishing a solid foothold in the competitive automotive landscape. ...Read more
Automotive manufacturing relies heavily on spot welding to ensure structural integrity and safety. Testing these welds has become more advanced, driven by the demand for higher accuracy, efficiency, and cost-effectiveness. Traditional destructive methods once dominated the process, but modern innovations now emphasize non-destructive approaches, digital integration, and real-time monitoring. These shifts help manufacturers improve quality assurance, reduce material waste, and maintain consistent standards across production lines. The evolution of spot weld testing reflects a broader push toward smarter, safer, and more sustainable automotive manufacturing practices. Advancing Non-Destructive Testing Methods Non-destructive testing has gained prominence in automotive spot weld analysis. Techniques such as ultrasonic inspection, resistance measurement, and radiographic imaging allow manufacturers to assess weld quality without damaging components. This approach preserves valuable materials while providing reliable insights into weld strength and consistency. Ultrasonic methods, for example, can identify internal flaws that may not be visible externally, ensuring welds meet stringent safety requirements. Resistance-based techniques measure electrical conductivity to determine whether a weld maintains proper bonding. These methods save both time and resources while offering greater precision compared to destructive alternatives. By adopting non-destructive testing, manufacturers create more efficient workflows and maintain higher levels of product reliability. Digital Integration And Real-Time Monitoring Digital transformation has also reshaped spot weld testing. Advanced software platforms now collect, process, and analyze data instantly during production. Real-time monitoring enables immediate detection of weak welds, allowing corrective actions before flaws impact larger batches. This proactive approach minimizes downtime, enhances safety, and improves overall efficiency on assembly lines. Integration of sensors and automated systems further streamlines the process. Connected devices record detailed parameters, including current flow, electrode pressure, and weld duration, creating digital records for traceability and compliance. These data-driven systems enhance transparency and also support predictive maintenance, reducing equipment failures and optimizing long-term production performance. The combination of non-destructive testing and digital monitoring has set a new standard for quality assurance in automotive manufacturing. By embracing these trends, manufacturers strengthen safety, reduce waste, and improve cost efficiency. Spot weld testing continues to evolve, positioning itself as a cornerstone of modern automotive production where precision and innovation go hand in hand. ...Read more
Maintaining constant quality and structural integrity is still an underlying principle in the changing automotive manufacturing world. Spot welding has been on the critical list of joining methods for sheet metal components in vehicle body assembly. The assurance of the strength of these welds is not just quality assurance but a matter of utmost importance for vehicle safety and performance. With increasingly complex designs and broader use of light materials, the evaluation methods for spot welds have transitioned to meet the new technical and regulatory demands. New Approaches to Spot Weld Quality Testing The most traditional methods to test spot welds have been mostly destructive, relying heavily on peeling testing and cross-sectioning. While these methods certainly give the most direct impression of weld strength and nugget formation ideas, they also destroy or significantly mark test specimens, increasing costs and time. Thus, manufacturers and designers are looking more toward non-destructive techniques (NDT), which preserve the integrity of the component but give an accurate reading. Ultrasonic and electromagnetic tests are widely practiced for the real-time assessment of welding quality in manufacturing. The ultrasonic systems recognize discrepancies, voids, or incomplete fusion using sound waves reflected throughout the weld material. The electromagnetic technique measures changes in electrical conductivity, which allows manufacturers to conduct tests online as production is being carried out. With improvements in imaging technologies and sensor integration, other approaches for spot weld testing were developed, allowing surface and subsurface analysis. Such tools foster data-oriented quality assurance, complying with industry standards and adjusting processes. Material Variability and Joint Complexity As automotive manufacturers increasingly utilize high-strength steels and lightweight alloys, spot weld testing challenges are growing. Such materials present unique issues concerning weld formation and heat, thus impacting the accuracy and reliability of testing methods. For instance, high-strength steel may have small weld nuggets that are more technically challenging to detect and measure. Conversely, aluminum alloys require close monitoring of consistency in welding because of the high thermal conductivity and oxide layer formation. Furthermore, multi-material joints and advanced joining techniques require testing solutions capable of populating a spectrum of material behaviors and properties along various weld configurations. Consequently, engineers need to consider the adaptability of testing protocols for geometry, thickness, and surface treatment modifications. This calls for increased attention to simulation and modeling tools with which the design phase predicts weld performance and potential for failure. Such predictive capabilities suggest a much more focused approach towards inspection strategies by reducing the scope of testing and moving towards a more productive testing scenario. The other pertinent factor influencing spot-weld testing arises from the ongoing build-out of production automation systems. Robotic welders with intelligent monitoring facilities can monitor real-time process variables like current, pressure, and time. The combination of this data and the outputs from testing allows manufacturers to correlate their understanding of weld integrity with process performance. However, giving testing systems versatility from different points of automation systems and cultures of varied production speed is an area to keep focus on continuously. Data Management and Analytics Another field that remains paramount in achieving long-term quality goals is managing and interpreting the test data, away from the technical aspect. As such, inspection systems generate more input data, and the need to organize, analyze, and act on this data grows. Current software platforms provide a holistic aggregation of weld test results across different production lines and locations, thus presenting a centralized real-time monitoring dashboard where the data can be historically viewed. Utilizing statistical prosthetics and machine-learning algorithms, trends can be tracked, deviations quickly apparent, and corrective actions undertaken by manufacturers. These applications ultimately form an underlying strategy for predictive maintenance, whereby test data is utilized for early warning to call for maintenance regarding preventing defects. Thus, the data obtained through spot weld testing are measures of present quality and a measure for improving future performance. Proper data integration would assure compliance with documentation and regulations attached to customer specifications. Manufacturers could use the detailed record of weld test results for traceability to demonstrate that they adhered to the specification. This transparency increases competitiveness among suppliers and is also essential for obtaining certifications for safety-critical applications like structural frames and crash management systems. Notwithstanding changes in automotive production, spot weld testing will remain an integral aspect of quality assurance. The continued development of ever more refined, responsive, and intelligent systems for conducting tests commits itself now to precision and absolute reliability at every stage of the manufacturing process. In addressing the technical and operational challenges of contemporary vehicle assembly, advanced testing of welds adds critical value to ensure that structural integrity remains uncompromised at every moment. ...Read more